The trophy is an item Annalise Keating uses to motivate the Keating Five. Originally, it causes dissent and suspicion among them. It is first awarded to Connor Walsh, then given to Laurel Castillo and finally Asher Millstone. Michaela Pratt steals it from Asher and tries to turn it in the night Sam Keating is killed, but Wes Gibbins ends up using it to hit and kill Sam. After, Laurel has Frank return it without making them look suspicious. He eventually claims he found it on the front porch to Annalise's house and declares it up for grabs again. However, the Keating Five now want to avoid it after killing someone with it.